American Idol - Top 12 guys take to the stage
February 25, 2010 by David · Leave a Comment
The guys took to the stage last night and seemed to be able to get rid of the nerves much more effectively than the girls in their Tuesday performances.
The highest praise seemed to go to Casey James, who sang the Brian Adams song, “Heaven.” Kara called him eye candy and also ear candy. Simon Cowell considered it honest and sincere.
Simon and Ellen were split on Aaron Kelly, who sang the Rascall Flatts hit, “Here Comes Goodbye.” Cowell commented, “You look at the moment as if you are embarrassed to be there.” However, Ellen acknowledged that as part of his appeal stating, “I love how humble you are.”
Some of the crash and burn performances included Todrick Hall, who sang “Since U Been Gone.” Randy called it a complete obliteration of the origina and Cowell incorporated the words “murder,” “stupid” and “torture” in his opinion of the performance. Also included in this category are Alex Lambert and John Park. Let’s see who goes home…
